Introduction to Captive Insurance: Complete Guide for Business Owners

Q: Are captives primarily a tax strategy?

No, captives should never be formed primarily for tax reasons. Legitimate captives must have valid business purposes beyond tax advantages and face IRS scrutiny if lacking proper risk transfer.

Key Takeaways

A captive is an insurance company owned by the businesses it insures
Captives provide control over insurance programs, access to reinsurance, and potential cost savings
Types include single-parent, group, association, and cell captives
Minimum premium volume of $1-2 million typically needed to justify formation
Domicile selection significantly impacts regulatory requirements and costs

Introduction to Captive Insurance

Captive insurance represents one of the most significant developments in corporate risk management over the past 50 years. What began as a tool for large corporations frustrated with traditional insurance markets has evolved into a sophisticated risk financing mechanism used by organizations of all sizes across virtually every industry.

Today, over 7,000 captive insurance companies operate worldwide, managing hundreds of billions of dollars in premium. Fortune 500 companies, mid-sized businesses, professional groups, and even small companies use captives to gain control over their insurance programs, reduce costs, and access coverage unavailable in traditional markets.

This guide provides a comprehensive introduction to captive insurance—explaining what captives are, how they work, and the key factors to consider when evaluating whether a captive structure is appropriate for your organization.

What Is a Captive Insurance Company?

A captive insurance company is a licensed insurance company created and owned by one or more organizations to insure the risks of its owner(s). Rather than purchasing insurance from third-party commercial insurers, the parent organization(s) establish their own insurance company to cover some or all of their risks.

Key Characteristics

Owned by insureds: The captive is owned by the same entities it insures
Licensed insurer: Captives are regulated insurance companies, not informal arrangements
Controlled by owners: The parent determines coverage, pricing, and risk appetite
Retains underwriting profit: Favorable loss experience benefits the owner, not external insurers

The term "captive" originated because these insurance companies are "captive" to their parent organizations—they exist primarily to serve the insurance needs of their owners rather than the general public.

Types of Captive Insurance Companies

Single-Parent Captive

Also called "pure captive." Owned by one parent company to insure only that company and its affiliates.

• Full control over program
• Maximum flexibility
• Requires significant premium volume
• Most common captive type

Group Captive

Owned by multiple unrelated companies, often in the same industry, sharing risks and costs.

• Lower individual capital requirements
• Risk spreading among members
• Less individual control
• Suitable for smaller companies

Association Captive

Sponsored by a trade association or professional group for members of that organization.

• Industry-specific coverage
• Shared governance
• Access for smaller members
• Homogeneous risk pool

Cell Captive / PCC / SPC

Protected Cell Company or Segregated Portfolio Company—participants rent "cells" within an existing structure.

• Lower startup costs
• Faster formation
• Assets legally segregated
• Good entry point for captives

Other Captive Structures

• Rent-a-Captive: Use another company's captive infrastructure without ownership
• Agency Captive: Owned by an insurance agency to share in underwriting profits
• Risk Retention Group (RRG): US-specific structure for liability coverage
• Special Purpose Vehicle (SPV): For specific risk transfer transactions

How Captive Insurance Works

Basic Captive Structure

Parent Capitalizes Captive

The parent company provides initial capital to meet regulatory requirements and support operations

Parent Pays Premium to Captive

The parent pays insurance premiums to its captive, just as it would to any insurer

Captive Issues Policies

The captive issues insurance policies to cover the parent's risks

Captive Pays Claims

When losses occur, the captive pays claims from its reserves

Captive Purchases Reinsurance

The captive cedes excess risk to reinsurers, limiting its exposure

The Role of Reinsurance

Reinsurance is critical to captive operations. Captives typically retain predictable, expected losses while transferring catastrophic or volatile risks to reinsurers. This allows the captive to benefit from favorable loss experience while protecting against severe outcomes.

Benefits of Captive Insurance

Cost Control & Savings

• Eliminate insurer profit margins and overhead
• Retain underwriting profit from good loss experience
• Earn investment income on reserves
• Reduce premium taxes (in some structures)
• Smooth insurance costs over time

Program Control

• Design coverage to match specific needs
• Set appropriate policy terms and conditions
• Control claims handling and settlement
• Determine loss control priorities
• Independence from market cycles

Coverage Access

• Cover risks unavailable in traditional markets
• Access reinsurance markets directly
• Maintain coverage during hard markets
• Fill gaps in commercial coverage
• Insure emerging or non-traditional risks

Strategic Benefits

• Formalize risk management practices
• Build equity in an insurance asset
• Potential tax advantages (consult advisors)
• Create profit center from risk management
• Demonstrate commitment to safety

Key Considerations

Important Challenges

• Capital commitment: Initial capitalization of $250,000 to several million
• Ongoing costs: Management fees, actuarial, audit, regulatory fees
• Regulatory compliance: Licensed insurers face regulatory requirements
• Management attention: Board meetings, governance, strategic decisions
• Adverse loss experience: Poor results impact the parent directly
• Complexity: More complex than simply buying insurance

Minimum Premium Thresholds

As a general guideline, organizations should have at least $1-2 million in annual insurance premium to justify a single-parent captive. Group captives and cell structures can work for smaller premium volumes. Below these thresholds, the fixed costs of captive operation typically outweigh the benefits.

Captive Formation Process

Formation Timeline (Typically 3-6 Months)

Phase 1: Feasibility Study

Analyze current insurance costs, loss history, and risk profile. Determine if a captive makes economic sense.

Phase 2: Business Plan Development

Define captive structure, coverage lines, capital requirements, reinsurance strategy, and financial projections.

Phase 3: Domicile Selection

Choose the jurisdiction based on regulatory environment, costs, expertise, and service provider availability.

Phase 4: Application & Licensing

Submit application to regulators, including business plan, financial statements, and governance documents.

Phase 5: Operationalization

Capitalize the captive, issue policies, arrange reinsurance, and begin operations.

Domicile Selection

The domicile (jurisdiction) where a captive is licensed significantly impacts regulatory requirements, capital needs, and ongoing costs. Key factors in domicile selection include:

Selection Factors

• Regulatory sophistication and stability
• Capital requirements
• Annual fees and taxes
• Service provider availability
• Political and economic stability
• Time zone and accessibility

Major Domiciles

• US: Vermont, Delaware, Utah, Nevada
• Caribbean: Bermuda, Cayman Islands, BVI
• Europe: Luxembourg, Ireland, Malta, Guernsey
• Asia-Pacific: Labuan, Singapore, Hong Kong

Ongoing Captive Management

Captives require ongoing management and governance. Most captive owners engage captive management companies to handle day-to-day operations, though board-level oversight remains with the parent.

Key Management Functions

Policy issuance and administration
Claims management
Financial reporting
Regulatory filings

Actuarial analysis
Investment management
Reinsurance placement
Board and governance support

Is a Captive Right for Your Organization?

Good Captive Candidates Typically:

Pay $1M+ in annual insurance premium
Have good loss experience and loss control
Face coverage gaps in traditional markets
Are frustrated with commercial market volatility
Have management commitment to risk management
Can commit capital and management attention

Captives May Not Be Suitable If:

Premium volume is too small to absorb fixed costs
Loss experience is poor or unpredictable
Management lacks commitment to the structure
Capital constraints prevent adequate funding
Primary motivation is tax avoidance (red flag)

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does it cost to form a captive?

Formation costs typically range from $50,000 to $100,000+ depending on complexity. This includes feasibility studies, legal work, actuarial analysis, and licensing fees. Annual operating costs range from $75,000 to $200,000+ for management, audit, actuarial, and regulatory fees.

What's the minimum capital required?

Minimum capital requirements vary by domicile and captive type, typically ranging from $100,000 to $500,000 for pure captives. However, actual capital needs depend on retained risk levels and may be significantly higher than regulatory minimums.

Are captives primarily a tax strategy?

While captives can offer tax benefits, they should never be formed primarily for tax reasons. Legitimate captives must have valid business purposes beyond tax advantages. Captives lacking proper risk transfer or business substance face IRS scrutiny and potential penalties.

How long does it take to form a captive?

Typical formation takes 3-6 months from initial feasibility analysis to licensing. Expedited formations can occur in 60-90 days in some domiciles. Cell captive arrangements can be implemented even faster since the structure already exists.

Can small companies use captives?

Yes, through group captives, cell captives, or risk retention groups. These structures allow smaller companies to access captive benefits by sharing infrastructure and pooling risks with others. Minimum premiums of $100,000-$250,000 may be sufficient for these shared structures.

Considering a Captive Insurance Company?

Our team has extensive experience in captive feasibility analysis, formation, and management. Contact us to explore whether a captive structure is right for your organization.

Request a Consultation

Captive Insurance